From the mouths of babes
So, we have a friend whose 7 month old son just said "Mama ma ma" and they have this super cute video of it. This got me thinking... I have video of E talking too, but I never posted it. I think this was taken somewhere between 10-11 months.
What did she say? She said "All done."
On top of that, this week E clearly said "banana" while I was showing her how to sign the word "banana" out of a book we have (if you're wondering, she doesn't sign at all... probably too busy blabbing away). I then mentioned this to some other moms, saying I don't think it counts as she's mimicking us and not freely saying it on her own, as in saying to us "Banana" and pointing in wanting it eat one. These experienced moms promptly said that "Banana" counts as her saying a word (especially since she does know what a banana is). But if that's the case, E has been talking for months! So, did we miss her first word then?? If everything the other moms were telling me is true, then E's first word was either "dada" (for Ian) or "oh uh" (thought by me.. hehehe). First whole words (or actually phrases) could be "All done" or "Thank You".
What's your opinion on what the criteria for an official first word should be?
(p.s. Sorry for the incorrect uses of the " mark. It's too late for me to figure this out in my head. I'll have Ian fix them all later)












